The Hitman Logo
Mazzotti's on the Plaza


Meetings, Parties, Luncheons, Dinners, Special Events Weddings & Anniversaries. In addition to our Signature Italian, we also offer whatever cuisine your heart desires!

All prices include delivery (within Arcata, Eureka, and McKinleyville), chafer pans, serving utensils, setup and pickup. Prices also include your choice of utensils, plateware and napkins: you may choose paper or ceramic plates, plastic or stainless silverware at no extra charge. Linen napkins are an extra .75c each (our direct cost per unit), paper napkins are free.

Delivery charge, based on distance, to be applied to all orders outside of Eureka, Arcata and Mckinleyville. There is an automatic gratuity of 20% included to all catering invoices.

We also do all "to-go" style! (ten person per item minimum)

Download our catering menu in pdf format.


All main courses are served with garden salad, our homemade bread, and sun dried tomato butter Includes plates, napkins and utensils, set up and delivery.
Main Course:
Spaghetti*, Gluten Free Pasta*, Penne
Lasagna*, Meat or Veggie (Min 10)
Lasagna Bianca (Min 10)
Chicken Lasagna Bianca (Min 10)
Eggplant Parmigiana*
Eggplant Ricotta*
Fettuccini Alfredo*
Grilled Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo
Meat, Spinach* or Cheese*Ravioli
Creamy Pesto* choice of pasta
Cheese Tortellini* choice of sauce
Gnocchi * choice of sauce
Chicken Parmigiana:choice of pasta
Chicken Marsala: choice of pasta
* Denotes entree is or can be served vegetarian. Prices are subject to change and do not include tax or service charges.

Contact Jean Mazzotti: 707-822-1971


$4.00 per person (20 person minimum):

Classic Fruit Platter-

Mouth-watering display of fresh fruit of the season.

Classic Vegetable Platter-

Beautifully creative display of fresh vegetables of the season.

Italian Antipasti Platter-

Bountiful presentation of roasted and grilled seasonal vegetables.

$5.00 per person (20 person minimum):

Deep Fried Polenta-

Crispy Parmesan Polenta served with Mazzotti’s house marinara and pesto sauces for dipping.

Turkey, Avocado & Cream Cheese Wraps-

Creamy and fresh avocado, Cream Cheese and turkey wrapped in a flour tortilla.

Tomato, Basil & Mozzarella Crostini-

Toasted Crostini rubbed with fresh garlic and topped with a diced tomato, mozzarella and basil relish.

Artichoke Heart Cheesecake-

A savory artichoke heart flavored cheesecake with a Ritz cracker crust. Great for spreading on bread!

Roasted Bell Pepper Cheesecake-

A scrumptious bell pepper flavored cheesecake with Ritz cracker crust. Excellent for spreading on bread!

Grilled Portabella Mushrooms-

Mesquite grilled mushrooms brushed with Madeira garlic butter, served with bruschetta, and shaved Parmesan.

Chicken Breast, Basil & Mushroom Paté-

Sautéed chicken breast, mushrooms and basil blended into a savory, spreadable mousse. Served with Mazzotti’s house bread.

Classic Cheese and Meat Platter-

Turkey, Salami, roast beef, mozzarella and provolone served on a platter with Mazzotti’s house bread and mustard and Mayo.

Italian Marinated Chicken Wings-

Zesty Italian style wings served with Mazzotti’s marinara and ranch dressing.

$6.00 per person (20 person minimum):

Pancetta Wrapped Prawns-

Sumptuous baked prawns wrapped in Italian bacon and served with a garlic butter sauce.

Crab Stuffed Portabella Mushrooms-

Sautéed crab, spinach, carrots, onions, garlic breadcrumbs ricotta, Parmesan and mozzarella cheese stuffed in portabella mushrooms.

BBQ Bacon Meatballs-

Savory meatballs studded with roasted garlic and bacon, served in a tangy BBQ sauce.

Marinated Tortellini Skewers-

Tri-colored tortellini, tomatoes, olives & Mozzarella cheese marinated in Mazzotti’s Italian Dressing and skewered in an impressive display.

Italian Meatballs-

Savory meatballs served with Mazzotti’s house marinara sauce.

Deep Fried Mozzarella Balls-

Hand rolled and breaded mozzarella balls. Served warm with Mazzotti’s own marinara sauce.